Successful abuse argument and subsequent acquittals leads to 20-year-old retaining her good character

Litigators: Oliver Dean, Rebecca Applegarth 

Counsel: Alex Rynn 

Our client of good character, represented by Oliver Dean and Rebecca Applegarth, was acquitted of possession with intent to supply a controlled drug of class B, and being concerned in the supply of controlled drugs of class A and class B following a six-day trial at Croydon Crown Court. 

The case concerned an allegation that the defendants jointly possessed an imitation firearm with intent to cause fear of violence, following the release of video footage that captured the co-defendant threatening someone. It was accepted by the prosecution that our client had not been present during this incident. 

Our client was arrested in February 2026 at just 19 years old and remanded to HMP Bronzefield pending trial. 

The Prosecution Allegations 

It was alleged that our client had been jointly involved in the supply of controlled drugs alongside her boyfriend, and that she had been a willing participant who had acted freely. 

The prosecution relied on messages that had been sent by the co-defendant to our client that displayed drug menus and reference to the supply of controlled drugs. 

Defence Strategy 

The defence case focused on the abuse our client had been subjected to at the hands of her co-defendant during the course of their relationship, and the pressure she was under to avoid violence by any means necessary. As a qualified nail technician who worked long hours on her business, it was factually denied by our client that she was involved in the supply of drugs. 

Instructed counsel, Alex Rynn (5 St Andrew’s Hill), challenged the prosecution’s evidence and invited the jury to consider the prosecution’s own drug expert report which emphasised the quantity of cannabis found at the property was consistent with personal use. 

Careful analysis of the messages relied on by prosecution highlighted that the drugs our client was alleged to have been supplying were solely under the control of the co-defendant. In highlighting our client’s use of the word “his” within the evidence when referring to drugs found at the property, the defence were able to invite the jury to consider whether they could be sure our client had possession and control of any drugs supplied to another. 

Abuse of Process Argument 

At the Pre-Trial Review, just five days before trial, the co-defendant changed his pleas to guilty on all counts against him. The prosecution then stated before the court that they would no longer be pursuing the imitation firearm count against our client. 

The day before trial, the defence were informed that this had been a mistake and that the CPS had not intended to dismiss the count. On the morning of trial, Alex successfully argued that proceeding with the count would amount to an abuse and unfairly disadvantage our client. The defence relied on the case of Bloomfield, and the Court ruled that permitting the prosecution to proceed with the count would risk undermining public confidence in the administration of justice. 

Acquittals at Trial 

Following deliberations, the jury returned Not Guilty verdicts on all counts. 

The acquittals resulted in our client being released from HMP Bronzefield, and preserving her good character. At just 20 years old, a conviction could have had a detrimental impact on securing future employment. 

After trial, our client’s family thanked the team for their work on the case, “You answered all our worries and you never left her alone. You gave her her life back. We will never forget what you did for our family”.